If you have been buying mattresses in the past, then there is a high chance that you’ve come across or heard of Simmons Beautyrest and Serta brands. Simmons and Serta are some of the oldest, most popular mattress brands in the industry, and their mattress models are all over the country. Read this Beautyrest VS Serta mattress to know more about these two brands.
The Simmons bedding company was established in 1870 and offers a wide range of mattress models. On the other hand, Serta was started in 1931, and its first-ever mattress was the perfect sleeper mattress. Today, these two mattresses have one of the largest market shares, and they offer competitive products.
Comparison Chart: Beautyrest VS Serta Mattress
|Black, Harmony Lux, Hybrid
|iComfort, Perfect Sleeper, Sertapedic, Hotel Collection
|Memory Foam, Hybrid, Innerspring
|Firmness Scale (1-10):
|2 (Plush) – 8 (Firm)
|1 (Ultra Plush) – 9 (Extra Firm)
|Comfort Layer Materials:
|Memory Foam, Gel Foam, Micro Coils, Latex
|Memory Foam, Gel Foam, PillowTop, Latex
|Support Core Materials:
|Pocketed Coils, Foam
|Pocketed Coils, Foam, Continuous Coils
|Yes (Cool Action Gel)
|Free (Within contiguous US)
|Free (Within contiguous US)
|CertiPUR-US, GREENGUARD Gold
|CertiPUR-US, GREENGUARD Gold
|T3 Pocketed Coil, AirCool Memory Foam
|Serta’s Cool Twist Gel Foam, Serta Balanced Support Foam
|Check Today’s Price
|Check Today’s Price
Simmons is more focused on producing expensive and luxurious products, while Serta pays more attention to designing all kinds of products from cheap to expensive. But which brand is better or offers the best products?
Today, our focus will be on the well-performing Simmons Beautyrest series and Serta iComfort mattress series. Both of these mattresses have other collections under their belt. The Simmon Beautyrest series has collections like the Beautyrest Black collection, the platinum collection, and the silver collection. All these collections have several models under them as well. Serta comes with two different series, which are the Serta Perfect Sleeper and Serta iComfort. The Serta iComfort series has 23 models under its belt. All the 23 Serta iComfort models come with pocketed coil-in-coil support cores. The Simmons Beautyrest and Serta iComfort high-end series are competing favorably with other popular high-end mattress brands like the Casper mattress, Purple mattress, and Nectar foam mattress.
Since many people find a hard time deciding between these two mattresses, we’ve created this detailed review to help them make a simple choice. We have outlined their features, pros, cons, and who the mattress is better suited for.
Detail Features of the Beautyrest and Serta Mattress
Before we compare other features of this Beautyrest VS Serta mattress article, it is vital to know what every mattress comprises. These two are high-quality mattresses with great features. But what are they made of?
About Simmons Beautyrest Mattress
Simmons Beautyrest mattress comprises several layers that offer the required support and comfort to your body. The mattress features dual cool memory foam technology. This is a vital layer as it helps to move heat away from the bed’s surface so that the sleeper can remain cool and comfortable.
Another great layer of this mattress is the dynamic response memory foam. This is ventilated memory foam with a uniquely firm feel, and it helps to offer conforming back support. The Beautyrest also has gel touch foams, which are soft gel foam with outstanding conformability that offers soothing comfort to stomach sleepers.
The Foundation layer of the Beautyrest mattress is very thick, and it provides excellent support, durability, and reduced motion transfer. With the Beautyrest pocketed coil technology, the user of the mattress will experience enhanced conformability and pressure relief.
Check Today’s Price
About Serta iComfort Mattress
This is another durable and reliable high-end mattress. It comes with 4 layers that provide the right level of cushioning and support along the whole length of the body. The first layer is the gel memory foam that is infused with several active beads that regulate temperature and provide a cool-to-the-touch feel.
The second layer is the EverCool Fuze gel memory foam that provides temperature regulation throughout the entire night. So, there won’t be a lot of heat buildup as it promotes airflow. This layer is vital as it provides pressure point relief. Another important layer is the ultimate edge foam core that strengthens the mattress edges and supports your body throughout the night.
Check Today’s Price
A Good firm mattress should offers you the comfort that you need. Some mattresses are too firm or too soft for your comfort. That’s why you need to determine how comfortable a mattress is before purchasing it. In order to do this, you need to know the firmness level of the mattress.
Sert iComfort mattress has different firmness levels depending on the mattress model you’re choosing. The manufacturer did this deliberately in order to serve different people with different needs. From plush to gentle firm and firm, you will have to select a mattress that provides you the comfort that you need.
Just like Serta iComfort, the Simmons Beautyrest series has different firmness to offer from firm to plush and pillow top. But unlike Serta, Simmons focuses on providing plush and luxurious yet essentially responsive mattresses. So, you can easily choose the firmness level that you desire.
Movements at night from your partner can disturb your sleep, and that’s one of the reasons why you should select a mattress with excellent motion transfer so that you are not disturbed. Both the Serta iComfort and Simmons Beautyrest mattress series have great motion isolation.
The Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are usually innerspring and hybrid mattresses, hence it is created with responsive sleep surfaces, reduces, and isolates motion to a great extent due to its memory foam in the comfort layer. Furthermore, the mattress has a pocketed coil system that helps in preventing some motion transfer issues.
The Serta iComfort mattress is normally made up of viscoelastic foam-based materials, which are excellent at motion isolation. Also, some models have pocketed springs that are great at isolating motion.
Related article: Compare Serta vs Sealy in terms of motion control
Overall, Beautyrest has better motion isolation capabilities than Serta. So, if you want a mattress that will enable you to have a sound sleep with your partner, Beautyrest is the mattress for you.
Both the Serta and Beautyrest mattresses have good cooling features that keep the mattress cool; thus, they are good for hot sleepers. The iComfort mattress features innerspring and carbon fiber memory foam, but it is still able to stay cool the whole night. Also, Beautyrest has individually wrapped innerspring and hybrid beds that retain heat, and that’s why it is rated as being hotter than iComfort.
If you want a mattress that will keep you cool the whole night, then I would suggest you go for Serta iComfort as many users have selected it over Simmons Beautyrest.
Not all mattresses support your body as needed. When sleeping, you need a bed that conforms to your spinal alignment for better health. You don’t want to wake up feeling back pain, pain in the joints, hips, or shoulders.
When it comes to conformity, these two mattresses are good but not the best. This is because most of their models are either made of hybrid or innerspring mattresses, while memory foam mattresses and latex mattresses conform the best. Though these two mattresses have foam in their structure and this allows them to conform to some extent.
If you love sleeping or sitting on the edge of your mattress, then you will definitely fall in love with these mattresses. Since most of their mattresses are hybrid or innerspring mattresses, these two series offer one of the best edge support that a person can desire. Innerspring and hybrid mattresses provide strong edge support and very less likely to sink prematurely when you sit or sleep on the edge.
The Beautyrest mattress usually features foam-encased support cores, while iComfort has coil-based support cores.
This is another amazing feature where these two mattresses thrive because of their composition. Since the Serta iComfort and Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are mostly hybrid or innerspring mattresses, they are very responsive and don’t hug or sink a lot. As a result, you can move on this mattress or change position easily without being held back.
Are you a couple looking for the perfect mattress for your bedroom or for sex? Worry not as both of these mattresses flourish in this area. Back to the same point, Serta and Beautyrest have innerspring and hybrid beds, which are normally bouncy and more responsive than memory foam mattresses. Therefore, couples will have an easy time on these mattresses as they can change positions easily or have sex without any problems.
Off-gassing and smell
Even though both of these mattresses produce a smell after being unpacked, Simmons Beautyrest mattress produces more smell than Serta. You may be wondering why this is so since they are both feature innerspring and hybrid mattresses. Yes, it is true that they are made of similar materials, but Beautyrest is made with more memory foam than Serta, which makes it produce more smell. This smell may last from a few hours to some few days before it disappears completely. So, it is not something to be stressed about.
Not all mattresses are silent or noisy. Note that innerspring and hybrid mattresses like Winkbeds or Eco Terra mattresses are usually noisy, but memory foam mattresses are virtually silent. Hence, as you prepare to buy your mattress, you should keep this in mind so that you don’t end up regretting later.
The Serta iComfort mattress series is usually louder than the Simmons Beautyrest series as their mattresses are innerspring or hybrid, which produce noise when weight is placed on them. The Beautyrest mattresses are normally made of foam, which is silent, but they still produce minimal noise because some models feature innerspring and hybrid mattresses.
With so many models and sizes to choose from, this can be a hard task. But if you narrow it down to either twin, queen, or king-size beds with similar features, you will find that Serta products are cheaper than Simmons products. So, if you’re tight on the budget and want an affordable but still quality mattress for your bedroom, then you should consider buying from Serta. Simmons focuses on the quality of their mattresses, and that’s why they are slightly costly than other mattress brands on the market.
Trial period and return
If you want to choose a mattress based on the trial period, I would suggest that you go with Beautyrest instead of Serta. This is regardless of them having the same trial period of 120-nights. Serta has a mandatory break-in period of 30 nights, while Beautyrest doesn’t. Also, there is a fee charged for returning Serta mattresses while Beautyrest doesn’t have. So, in the long run, it may end up costing you more.
Warranty and shipping
Serta iComfort comes with a better warranty period than Simmons Beautyrest. Like hybrid Big Fig Mattress, Serta also offers its clients a 20-year warranty, while Simmons provides a 10-year warranty. With such great warranties, you can be assured that you are buying from some of the best and reliable brands in the country.
- These two mattresses come with an exceptional trial period of 120-nights.
- Both of these mattresses have great edge support.
- Simmons Beautyrest and Serta iComfort are quality and durable mattresses that offer comfort as well.
- Serta is way cheaper than Beautyrest
- It offers a 20-year warranty while Beautyrest has a 10-year warranty
- Serta customer service is one of the best when compared to average or below-average customer support from Simmons Beautyrest.
Advantages of Serta memory foam
- Serta offers all types of mattresses, from budget-friendly to expensive ones
- It provides highly innovative memory foam mattresses
- Serta has a great variety to choose from in terms of support cores
- it has an excellent customer support team
- Because of its great edge support, this is a standard mattress for side sleepers.
Disadvantages of Serta
- Several users have complained that the mattress has high heat retention
- It produces a higher than the average off-gassing smell. If you want to get rid of the off-gassing smell, an innerspring Avocado green mattress would be an ideal deal for you.
- It charges returns, unlike other top brands that offer free services
Advantages of Beautyrest Mattress
- The brand is focused on producing durable, reliable, and comfortable mattresses.
- Its main focus is to produce high-quality mattresses, which can be seen even with its least expensive mattress models.
- It features pocketed coil technology, which is very good when it comes to comfort and breathability.
- Beautyrest has above-average motion isolation capabilities
- The mattresses are available in many brick-and-mortar stores around the country
Related article: Comparison chart between Sealy and Beautyrest mattress
Disadvantages of Beautyrest
- The mattress has a limited selection when compared to Serta
- It is quite expensive when compared to Serta mattresses.
- They are not very durable as clients have complained about sagging after some time of use.
Who is Beautyrest made for?
- This mattress is suitable for a wide range of sleepers as it features 24 different innerspring and hybrid mattress models for great comfort.
- The Beautyrest mattresses are suitable for couples as they offer above-average support but have a very responsive surface.
- This is a good mattress for those who sleep hot as it has proper ventilation on every section of the mattress augments. This keeps you cool the whole night.
Who shouldn’t choose Beautyrest?
- If you want a mattress with great motion isolation, then you should look elsewhere. For best motion isolation, you should choose a mid-firmed Helix mattress because it reduces motion transfer.
- The mattresses are slightly above average price and not ideal for a person looking for a pocket-friendly but still quality mattress.
Who is Serta made for?
- This is an excellent mattress for couples as the innerspring bed bounces a lot and is more responsive. This is a great bed for sex as well.
- If you sleep hot and want a mattress that keeps cool the whole night, Serta is a great choice. The innerspring feature will help to promote the circulation of air, thus allowing you to sleep cool.
- If you love sleeping or sitting on the edge of the mattress, you will be glad to have this mattress. This is because it has a suitable sleeping surface.
Who shouldn’t choose Serta?
- If you are looking for an extremely durable mattress, the Serta shouldn’t be on top of your priorities as it will perform great for just 7 years.
Which is better? Beautyrest or Serta Mattress?
After reading this Beautyrest VS Serta comparison, it is clear that these are some of the best mattress models on the market. The mattresses are compatible in so many ways, but they also have their own differences. As a result, the final decision lies in what your preferences are.
If you want a luxurious hybrid mattress in 2024 that combines the peak development in terms of pocketed coil technology with memory foam that remains cool and comfortable as you sleep, then you should go with Simmons Beautyrest.
But if you are on a budget and want a high-quality but still affordable mattress or want a traditional innerspring bed with gel cooling foam technology, then the Serta iComfort mattress is the best option for you.
Overall, we highly recommend Serta as it has even been approved by the National Sleep Foundation. But this doesn’t mean that the Simmons Beautyrest mattress series isn’t great as it is also exceptional.
Still, have questions after reading this Beautyrest VS Serta mattress article? Comment below.