Beautyrest VS Sealy Mattress Comparison Chart in 2025

Last Updated on January 7, 2025

Simmons Beautyrest and Sealy are two of the most popular mattress brands on the market, which makes choosing your next mattress from one of them to be very challenging. Both of these brands offer quality mattresses with exceptional services. They are also priced well and have outstanding features. But which one is better? Read this Beautyrest VS Sealy Mattress article to find out the answer.

Both of these mattresses have been in the industry for a longer period. Sealy mattress has been in existence for more than 130 years, while Simmons Beautyrest mattress has been in existence for more than 140 years. In addition, these two mattress brands have the same sleep trial period of 120 days and a 10-year non-prorated warranty. Besides, they are very reliable and have positive customer reviews.

Comparison Chart: Beautyrest VS Sealy Mattress

Features	Beautyrest	Sealy
Layers	3	2
Durability	4-5 years	7 years
Sleeping positions	Couple and combo sleepers	Side sleepers, Back sleepers
Edge Support	Yes	Yes
Mattress size	Twin XL, Queen, King, California King, and Twin	Twin, Queen, California King, King, and Twin xl
Firmness	plush, soft, medium-firm, and firm	3.5, and the firm feel is 6.5/7.5
Motion Isolation:	poor	isolate and absorb motion
Trial period	120 nights	120 nights
Off-gassing	a day or two	little to no
Noise	Silent	slightly noisier
Price	Above average	Affordable
Warranty	10-year penetrated warranty	10-year limited warranty
Price:	Check Today’s Price	Check Today’s Price

Contents

Features Details of the Beautyrest VS Sealy

If you want to know which mattress is better suited for your needs, then read this Beautyrest VS Sealy review as we’ve highlighted their features, pros, cons, and “who is” and “who is” not better suited for a certain type of mattress.

Simmons Beautyrest construction

The owner and distributor of Beautyrest mattress is the well-known Serta brand. The Simmons Beautyrest mattress is made up of 3 major mattress series, which are the Black Collection, Platinum Collection, and Silver Collection. These mattresses are made up of innerspring and hybrid mattresses. Beautyrest Black collection comprises of innerspring mattresses like Tatiana, Natasha, Desiree, and Sonya; the Platinum collection is made up of models like Quinn, Bryson, Gabriella plush Pillow TOP, and Amberlyn; while the Silver collection is made up of mattress models like Cascade mist, Charcoal Coast Pillow Top, and Open Seas.
Check Today’s Price
In most cases, mattress Beautyrest comes with 4 layers, which are made up of different materials. The first layer is usually thin and features a breathable material like memory or gel touch foam. The second layer is also made of a comfort layer that offers good conforming to the user’s body. The other two layers are usually for providing comfort or support. Ensure that you pick the right mattress that has the construction that meets your needs.

Sealy Posturepedic construction

The Sealy Posturepedic mattress is a hybrid mattress that features coils and foams in its layers. It is made up of 3 layers, which are memory foam transition and pocketed coils. The mattress is 12 inches in thickness, which is great for providing enough support and comfort to the owner of the mattress. B
Check Today’s Price
The first layer is made up of zoned support coils. These not only make the bed be breathable, but they also offer the comfort that the user needs. The second layer is the memory foam layer, and it is ideal for supporting the weight and also offering the needed comfort. It also isolates motion and absorbs some heat. The final and base layer features pocketed coil technology. These give the bed its bouncy feel and allow the air to circulate freely, which prevents the mattress from trapping heat. A typical hybrid mattress usually has around 1000 coils in its structure.

Durability

Durability is one of the major complaints when it comes to both Beautyrest and Sealy mattresses. Most owners complain that these mattresses don’t last more than 7 years. The Sealy Essentials and Performance series have been discovered to have a shorter lifespan when compared to the Sealy Premium series. On the other hand, many Beautyrest owners have complained that mattresses start to show indentations after 4 to 5 years. When compared, it is clear that the Sealy mattress is more durable than the Beautyrest mattress.

So, if you’re looking for a very durable mattress model, then you should consider getting the Sealy Posturepedic mattress or the Amerisleep hybrid mattress. It will last for 7 or more years when properly maintained.

Firmness

Most Sealy mattresses have either a plush firm or a firm feel. The plush firm is 3.5, and the firm feel is 6.5/7.5, depending on the model. The Sealy Posturepedic mattress has a medium firmness, which is 1-10 on the firmness rating scale. So, if you want a Sealy mattress that is soft or firm, you should look beyond the Sealy Posturepedic technology.

On the other hand, the Simmons Beautyrest mattress has a lot of mattress firmness to choose from. You can choose plush, soft, medium-firm, and firm. Make sure that you pick a well-firmed mattress with a good firmness rating so that it can offer you comfort and relieve pain and aches.

Motion isolation

Both of these mattresses are not good at isolating motion. Many users have complained that these mattresses are lacking when it comes to isolating motion. The Simmons Beautyrest has innerspring and hybrid mattresses that feature coils in their structure. But when compared to other innerspring and hybrid mattresses, they isolate and absorb motion to some extent.

Unlike the Beautyrest mattress, the Sealy mattress is poor in isolating motion as most of its models are innerspring mattresses. These usually have many coils in their structure, which makes the mattress very bouncy and cannot absorb motion to a great extent. Charles P Rogers latex Mattress and Bear hybrid mattress both are excellent at absorbing isolating motion.

Temperature neutrality

The Sealy mattress is one of the best mattresses for hot sleepers as it sleeps very cool. The Sealy Posturepedic mattress is an innerspring mattress with coils in its structure. This allows air to circulate and prevents heat buildup freely. Beautyrest is also good at cooling the mattress but not as well as the Sealy mattress. Some users have complained that it sleeps hot. This is because the Beautyrest mattress has memory foam in its structure, which traps some heat, causing it to sleep hot.

Conforming

Depending on the Beautyrest model that you acquire, you will find that a hybrid mattress conforms more than innerspring mattresses. So, if you want to relieve pressure points or have a mattress hug you closely, then you will opt for Simmons Beautyrest mattresses that are made of hybrid and not innerspring.

The Sealy mattress offers very little conforming as it is an innerspring mattress. It is very bouncy and responsive. So, you won’t be getting a lot of pressure relief if you decide to choose this mattress over Simmons Beautyrest.

Edge support

Innerspring mattresses normally have excellent edge support as they usually have edges encased to offer support. With this type of support, you don’t have to worry about your partner who sleeps all over the bed as you can sleep at the edge of the mattress. The Sealy hybrid has good edge support, and so are the Beautyrest mattresses made of innerspring. But for luxury hybrid mattresses, the support is not as strong as in innerspring mattresses, though it is better than memory foam.

Off-gassing

When most mattresses are unpackaged, they tend to produce some smell, which may last from a few hours to several days. Memory foam mattresses are the biggest culprits as they are notable for off-gassing, and their smell may last from 24 hours to two days. Sealy Hybrid is an innerspring mattress with little to no off-gassing. This means you will be able to use the mattress within a few hours after unpacking it. For the Beautyrest mattress, you may have to wait for a day or two as it features memory foam, which produces a lot of smell.

Noise

Most of the memory foam mattresses are known to be the most silent, and at times, they don’t even produce any noise. But for innerspring and hybrid mattresses are notorious for producing noise as they have coils in their structure that squeak or creak when movements are made on them or when weight is placed on them. That’s why Beautyrest hybrid mattresses are slightly more silent than their innerspring counterpart. Also, since Sealy is purely innerspring, expect it to be slightly noisier than Beautyrest, which has memory foam in its structure.

Sex

A bouncy bed is a responsive bed. So, the more responsive the bed is, the more bouncy it will be. This is the case with the Sealy mattress. This bed is ideal for sex when compared to Beautyrest as it has a greater bounce and it is more responsive.

Price

Pricewise, we highly recommend the Sealy mattress as it has some affordable beds on offer. Beautyrest mattresses are slightly above the average price. So, if you want a quality bed with outstanding features, you should go for the Sealy hybrid Posturepedic bed instead of the Simmons Beautyrest models. But if you are a budget shopper, then go for the affordable eco-friendly Bloom mattress.

Trial period

This is an essential factor if you want enough time to test whether the mattress is good for you or not. The industry standard for a trial is at 100 nights, while both of these mattresses have a 120-night trial period. Four months is enough to know if the mattress is good for you or not.

Returns and shipping

Additionally, both of these mattresses offer free shipping, but it may take longer to arrive at your doorstep. So, you will have to be patient. Moreover, these two mattresses offer a full refund in case you are not fully contented with the mattress.

Note that these two mattresses do not offer old mattress removal. So, you will have to inquire before purchasing the mattress.

Warranty

Another great feature that both of these mattresses share is the 10-year non-prorated warranty. This is a good sign, and both mattress brands can be trusted. With a 10-year warranty, you can be certain that your investment is covered as long as you don’t violate the warranty. Also, the warranty cannot be transferred to a third party.

Advantages of Beautyrest Mattress

The mattress is great at minimizing motion transfer.
It provides above-average edge support.
The mattress is good at conforming, which relieves pressure.
It is very bouncy and responsive.
It conforms very well and has 24 models to choose from
The mattress offers great comfort, and it is of a high-quality
It works with all types of beds, such as box springs, adjustable bases, traditional frames, and platforms.
Simmons Beautyrest mattresses can be found in several brick-and-mortar stores around the country.
Beautyrest offers a 120-night free trial period.
It comes with a 10-year limited warranty.

Disadvantages of Beautyrest

It is not easy to rotate or flip the mattress. So it is difficult for an older person to flip or move the mattress. The Puffy mattress is ideal for older people because it provides consistent support and comfort to all types of sleepers.
The mattresses are sold at an above-average price, which may not be suitable for other people.
Off-gassing and mattress odor is more when compared to other similar mattresses.

Advantages of Sealy Mattress

It is very supportive and relieves pressure in sensitive parts of the body.
These mattresses are somehow cheap and offer a springy feeling.
They are very durable and will last for many years to come without losing their shape.
It allows the owner to sleep cool as it is made of natural breathing materials.
Sealy Mattress comes with a 120-night free trial period, which is exceptional.
It has a 10-year limited warranty.
Sealy Mattress offers free shipping and a full refund.
The mattress comes with advanced cooling technology.

Disadvantages of Sealy

The mattress is quite firm, which some overweight individuals may find to be uncomfortable. So if you are above 230lbs, you should check the reviews of our overweight people’s mattress list.
It has poor motion isolation.
Rotating these mattresses is not easy, nor is flipping them

Who should choose Beautyrest Mattress?

If you’re on a budget or are looking for an economical mattress, then the Simmons Beautyrest mattress should be your choice.
For people who want a luxurious and comfortable feel, then Simmons is a great mattress for you. Most of the Beautyrest mattresses feature coils and foam, which is comfortable and pressure relieving.
If you want different firmness options, you will like the Simmons Beautyrest mattress as it has firmness options that range from 3.5 to 7.5.
Beautyrest is a good mattress for you. If you want a conforming mattress that will relieve aches and pains in your body’s pressure points.
If you’re a couple looking for a bouncy mattress that is good for sex, then you will like Simmons Beautyrest mattress. It is also responsive; thus, you won’t have a hard time getting out of bed.

Who shouldn’t choose Beautyrest?

If you sleep hot, then look elsewhere, as many users have had complaints about some Simmons Beautyrest mattresses sleeping hot. Target the Layla Innerspring mattresses instead of the hybrid mattresses.
For someone who wants a virtually silent mattress, then you should also look elsewhere. The Simmons Beautyrest mattresses have coils in their structure, which make to produce some noise.

Who should choose Sealy Mattress?

If you like to change into different positions as you take a nap, this will be a great mattress for you. It is great for side, back, stomach, and combination sleepers.
This mattress can serve all kinds of people, from light sleepers who weigh 130 pounds or more to heavy sleepers who weigh 250 pounds or less.
If you love the feel of a memory foam mattress, then you will like this mattress. Also, the mattress is very supportive and will relieve pressure points on your body.
This is a great mattress for couples as it is not only bouncy but also responsive. Therefore, if you’re a couple looking for a good bed for sex, the Sealy Posturepedic is a good choice.
If you’ve got a partner who moves a lot in bed, then you will love this mattress as it is great at isolating motion.

Who shouldn’t choose Sealy?

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly bed, then this is not the bed for you as it is priced above average.
People who want a firm or soft bed mattress like Zenhaven then look elsewhere, as this mattress is of medium firmness. This also means that it is not ideal for very light or very heavy individuals.
If you don’t love the feel of memory foam, you will also not like this mattress. This is because the mattress is made of memory foam.

Which is better? Between Beautyrest VS Sealy Mattress?

The Sealy Posturepedic and Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are two amazing mattress models with exceptional features. Depending on your needs and budget, you may find the Sealy or Beautyrest to be ideal for you. These two offer their mattresses online, and they provide free delivery as well. However, their mattresses vary in construction and features.

The Sealy mattress is slightly expensive when compared to Simmons Beautyrest, which has a lot of mattresses to select from, and they vary in price. Also, the Sealy mattress is more bouncy and responsive than the Beautyrest mattress. Sealy is also good at offering a cool sleeping surface when compared to Beautyrest. The Beautyrest is a good mattress for couples who move a lot in bed as it minimizes motion transfer to a great extent.

Generally, these two mattresses are outstanding and can be relied on to offer the owner a good night’s sleep. Just pick one with the features that you want, and it should be of the right firmness level.

FAQs

1. Which mattress is better for back pain: Beautyrest or Sealy?
Both brands offer excellent support, but Sealy’s Posturepedic technology is specifically designed to target back pain relief by providing reinforced support for your lower back.

2. Do Beautyrest and Sealy mattresses last long?
Yes, both brands are known for their durability. Beautyrest mattresses typically last around 8-10 years, while Sealy mattresses can last 7-10 years with proper care.

3. Are Beautyrest mattresses more expensive than Sealy?
Generally, Beautyrest mattresses are priced slightly higher than Sealy mattresses due to their luxury features and advanced comfort layers.

4. Which brand is better for side sleepers: Beautyrest or Sealy?
Beautyrest mattresses are often preferred by side sleepers due to their plush comfort layers and better pressure relief for hips and shoulders.

5. Do Beautyrest and Sealy mattresses offer a sleep trial?
Yes, both brands offer sleep trials, but the duration and terms depend on the retailer. Be sure to check the retailer’s policy before purchasing.

Still have questions after reading this Beautyrest VS Sealy mattress? Comment below.