Tuft & Needle VS Lull Comparison[Which Mattress Should You Get?]

Last Updated on October 24, 2026

Tuft & Needle and Lull are two popular online mattress brands. If you start searching for the best affordable foam mattresses, there’s a good chance you’ll come across one of these names. Both companies offer comfortable mattresses with supportive foam layers, making it difficult for first-time buyers to choose between them.

In this Tuft & Needle vs Lull mattress comparison, we’ll examine their construction, firmness, pressure relief, motion isolation, cooling, durability, and overall value.

For 2026, we’re comparing the newer Tuft & Needle Original Mattress II with the Original Lull Mattress. Both are all-foam beds, but they have different comfort characteristics and warranty policies.

Our detailed comparison will help you understand their advantages, disadvantages, and which mattress is better suited to your sleeping position and budget.

Comparison Chart 2026: Tuft & Needle vs Lull Mattress

The Tuft & Needle Original has gone through several updates. The current Original Mattress II differs from the older 10-inch, two-layer model. Lull has also updated its policies and expanded its mattress collection.

Before buying, check the exact mattress version in the product listing. Older Tuft & Needle models may still be available through some retailers and have different specifications.

Tuft & Needle vs Lull Mattress Features Comparison in 2026

To choose the best mattress, you need to understand how each bed is built and how its materials affect comfort. This will also help you decide which mattress offers the right support for your sleeping position.

Tuft & Needle Construction

Tuft & Needle offers several mattresses, including all-foam and hybrid models. Our focus is the newer Tuft & Needle Original Mattress II, which is part of the brand’s updated mattress collection.

The Original II has a 12-inch profile and uses multiple foam layers to provide responsive comfort and support.

At the top is a cooling cover designed to improve surface comfort. Underneath is T&N Adaptive foam, which combines contouring pressure relief with a responsive feel. The foam contains cooling gel and heat-conducting graphite intended to help manage body heat.

The support foam provides cushioning and helps stabilize the mattress. A durable base foam forms the bottom layer and maintains the bed’s structure.

Unlike traditional slow-moving memory foam, T&N Adaptive foam responds more quickly when you change positions. This gives the mattress a slightly springier feel.

The Original II is marketed as firm, making it appealing to sleepers who prefer a more supportive surface.

Tuft & Needle also continues to offer legacy versions of the Original mattress, including the older medium-firm design. Make sure you’re comparing the same version when shopping.

Check Today’s Price

Lull Construction

The Original Lull Mattress is an all-foam bed with a 10-inch thickness profile. Unlike the newer Tuft & Needle Original II, Lull focuses more on the traditional memory foam experience.

The mattress has three primary foam layers designed to provide comfort, pressure relief, and support.

The top layer consists of gel-infused memory foam with an open-cell structure. It contours to the sleeper’s body and helps distribute weight around pressure-sensitive areas such as the shoulders and hips.

The middle layer uses high-resilience foam that provides responsive support and helps prevent excessive sinking. This layer also makes changing positions easier than it would be on a mattress made entirely of slow-moving memory foam.

Finally, the supportive base foam provides stability and maintains the mattress’s overall shape.

The Original Lull has a medium-firm feel, making it suitable for many average-weight sleepers.

It also uses CertiPUR-US certified foams and is designed to offer balanced comfort for different sleeping positions.

Check Today’s Price

Durability

Most good-quality all-foam mattresses are expected to provide comfortable use for approximately 6 to 10 years. However, the actual lifespan depends on foam quality, body weight, sleeping habits, and the supporting foundation.

Tuft & Needle uses durable support foam and responsive Adaptive foam, while Lull combines memory foam with high-resilience and base foams.

Both are designed for everyday use, but neither mattress can be guaranteed to outlast the other without long-term testing of the exact models.

A firmer mattress may resist deep impressions for some sleepers, while a softer mattress may show body impressions sooner under heavier loads.

To improve durability, use a suitable bed foundation and follow the manufacturer’s cleaning instructions.

Firmness

Firmness is one of the most important factors to consider when buying a mattress.

The current Tuft & Needle Original II is marketed as firm. It provides a supportive, responsive sleeping surface with less deep sinking than many traditional memory foam beds.

The Original Lull has a medium-firm feel. Its memory foam comfort layer allows the body to settle into the surface while the layers underneath provide support.

For lightweight side sleepers, Lull may offer more comfortable cushioning around the shoulders and hips.

Back and stomach sleepers who prefer a firmer surface may find Tuft & Needle more appealing.

However, firmness is subjective. Your body weight and preferred sleeping position can change how either mattress feels.

Pressure Relief

Both mattresses are designed to relieve pressure, although they achieve this differently.

Lull features a memory foam comfort layer that conforms closely to the body’s shape. This can help distribute weight and reduce pressure around the shoulders and hips.

Tuft & Needle uses responsive Adaptive foam that cushions the body without creating the same deep hugging sensation.

If you prefer sleeping slightly “in” the mattress, Lull may be the better choice.

If you enjoy sleeping more “on” the mattress with easier movement, Tuft & Needle offers a more responsive feel.

Neither mattress guarantees relief from chronic pain. The best option is the one that keeps your body comfortably supported without placing excessive pressure on sensitive areas.

Motion Isolation

Foam mattresses are generally good at absorbing motion, which makes them popular among couples.

The Tuft & Needle Original II offers good motion isolation because its foam layers absorb movement before it travels across the bed.

Lull also performs well in this category. Its memory foam layer is particularly effective at absorbing smaller movements.

Although Tuft & Needle is more responsive, that doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll feel every movement from your partner.

Both mattresses are suitable for couples, but Lull may have a slight advantage for sleepers who prefer the motion-dampening characteristics of memory foam.

Edge Support

Edge support is one of the common weaknesses of all-foam mattresses.

Neither Tuft & Needle nor Lull uses the reinforced perimeter coils found in some hybrid mattresses.

The firmer Tuft & Needle Original II may feel more supportive around the edges for some sleepers, while Lull’s memory foam can compress when concentrated weight is applied.

However, both may sink noticeably when you sit directly on the edge.

If you need strong edge support for sitting or getting in and out of bed, consider a hybrid mattress with reinforced edges.

Temperature Regulation

Temperature regulation is another important difference in the Tuft & Needle vs Lull mattress comparison.

Tuft & Needle uses a cooling cover and graphite- and gel-infused Adaptive foam designed to improve heat management.

Lull uses open-cell memory foam with cooling gel beads intended to reduce heat retention.

Both offer cooling-focused materials, but neither all-foam mattress provides the same airflow as a traditional innerspring or hybrid bed.

Tuft & Needle may feel more breathable to sleepers who prefer less body contouring, while Lull’s memory foam may retain more warmth around the body.

For hot sleepers, Tuft & Needle has an advantage in its cooling-oriented design. However, actual temperature comfort depends on bedding, room temperature, and sleeping habits.

Responsiveness for Couples

Many couples prefer a mattress with enough responsiveness to make changing positions comfortable.

The Tuft & Needle Original II has responsive foam that returns to shape relatively quickly. This can make movement easier than on traditional slow-moving memory foam.

Lull also incorporates a high-resilience transition layer, which provides some bounce and prevents the surface from feeling excessively soft.

For couples who value easy movement, Tuft & Needle may have a slight advantage.

However, if you want both motion isolation and body contouring, Lull is an excellent option.

Noise

Both mattresses are virtually silent because they don’t contain traditional metal spring systems.

Their foam layers absorb weight without producing the squeaking or creaking associated with some older innerspring mattresses.

This makes both beds appealing to couples and people who want a quiet sleeping environment.

Remember that a loose or damaged bed frame can still produce noise, regardless of the mattress type.

Off-Gassing

Online foam mattresses are usually compressed before shipping. When unpacked, they may release a temporary new-mattress smell.

Both Tuft & Needle and Lull use CertiPUR-US certified foams, which meet established standards for foam content and emissions.

Some odor may still be noticeable after unboxing. It commonly decreases within a few days, although the time varies.

Place the mattress in a well-ventilated room and allow it to expand according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

Trial Period

This is one of the biggest changes compared with older mattress comparisons.

Tuft & Needle provides a 100-night sleep trial on eligible mattress purchases.

Lull now offers a 365-night sleep trial on eligible purchases through its official website.

This gives Lull customers considerably more time to decide whether their mattress is comfortable.

Return conditions may differ for mattresses purchased through Amazon or other retailers. Always check the seller’s return policy before ordering.

Shipping

Both companies offer free standard shipping to the contiguous United States on eligible mattress purchases.

Tuft & Needle states that most orders ship within several business days, although delivery times vary by location.

Lull also delivers its mattresses compressed in boxes, making them easier to transport through hallways and doorways.

Additional shipping charges or restrictions may apply to Alaska and Hawaii.

Pricing

Tuft & Needle and Lull both offer competitively priced mattresses, although the final cost depends on the model, size, and promotional discounts.

Tuft & Needle offers different Original versions, including lower-priced legacy options.

Lull frequently promotes discounts and bedding bundles with eligible mattress purchases.

Instead of comparing advertised discount percentages, check the final checkout price for the same mattress size.

Also consider the sleep trial, warranty, materials, and included accessories when comparing value.

Warranty

Tuft & Needle and Lull have different warranty policies in 2026.

Tuft & Needle: Offers a 10-year limited mattress warranty covering qualifying manufacturing and material defects.

Lull: Provides a limited lifetime warranty on eligible mattresses, subject to its warranty conditions.

Lull has an advantage in the length of coverage. However, a longer warranty doesn’t automatically mean the mattress will remain comfortable for a longer period.

Both warranties have exclusions for normal wear, misuse, and damage unrelated to manufacturing defects.

Review the official Tuft & Needle warranty terms and Lull mattress policies before purchasing.

About Tuft & Needle

Tuft & Needle was founded in 2012 and became one of the early companies to popularize affordable bed-in-a-box mattresses.

The brand later became part of Serta Simmons Bedding and expanded its mattress collection.

In 2026, Tuft & Needle offers several all-foam and hybrid models, including the Original Mattress II, Original Hybrid II, Mint, and other updated versions.

The brand is particularly well known for its responsive T&N Adaptive foam, which combines pressure relief with a more supportive feel than traditional slow-moving memory foam.

About Lull

Lull is another established direct-to-consumer mattress company focused on providing comfortable foam and hybrid beds at competitive prices.

The company has expanded beyond its original memory foam mattress.

Its current collection includes the Original Lull, Premium Lull, Luxe Hybrid, and Premium Luxe Hybrid mattresses.

The Original Lull remains a popular all-foam option because of its medium-firm feel, pressure-relieving memory foam, and straightforward construction.

The company’s 365-night trial and limited lifetime warranty are also important advantages for shoppers who want additional time and purchase protection.

Who Should Buy the Tuft & Needle Mattress?

• Firm Mattress Lovers: The Original II is suitable for people who prefer a supportive, firmer sleeping surface.
• Back and Stomach Sleepers: Its responsive foam may help sleepers who need additional support around the hips.
• Hot Sleepers: Cooling-focused foam materials and a cooling cover may help improve comfort.
• Combination Sleepers: Its responsive surface makes changing positions relatively easy.
• Budget-Conscious Shoppers: Tuft & Needle offers multiple Original models at different prices.
• People Who Dislike Deep Memory Foam Hugging: Adaptive foam provides cushioning without excessive sinkage.

Who Should Buy the Lull Mattress?

• Memory Foam Lovers: Lull provides the contouring comfort associated with traditional memory foam.
• Side Sleepers: Its cushioning comfort layer can help reduce pressure around the shoulders and hips.
• Couples: Very good motion isolation helps reduce disturbances during the night.
• Average-Weight Sleepers: Its medium-firm feel offers a balance of cushioning and support.
• Buyers Wanting a Longer Trial: Lull provides a 365-night trial on eligible purchases.
• Shoppers Who Value Warranty Coverage: Its limited lifetime warranty is longer than Tuft & Needle’s 10-year coverage.

Which Should You Pick: Lull or Tuft & Needle Mattress?

After comparing both mattresses, it’s clear that Tuft & Needle and Lull offer different sleeping experiences.

Choose Tuft & Needle Original II if you prefer a firmer mattress, responsive foam, cooling-focused materials, and easier movement when changing positions.

Choose Original Lull if you want traditional memory foam contouring, a medium-firm feel, strong motion isolation, and a longer home trial.

Both mattresses provide good comfort and support for many sleepers, but neither is automatically the best choice for everyone.

Your weight, sleeping position, and preferred firmness should determine which mattress you choose.

Overall, I prefer Tuft & Needle for sleepers who enjoy responsive, firmer foam. Lull is an excellent alternative for anyone who wants deeper contouring and more time to test the mattress at home.

I hope this Tuft & Needle vs Lull mattress comparison has helped you understand the differences and select the right bed for your needs in 2026.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which mattress is better for side sleepers: Tuft & Needle or Lull?

Lull may be more comfortable for many side sleepers because its memory foam provides cushioning around the shoulders and hips. The firmer Tuft & Needle Original II may be better for side sleepers who prefer a more supportive surface.

2. Does Tuft & Needle sleep cooler than Lull?

Tuft & Needle uses a cooling cover and graphite- and gel-infused Adaptive foam. Lull also features cooling gel and open-cell memory foam. Tuft & Needle may feel cooler for some sleepers, but neither all-foam mattress is guaranteed to prevent overheating.

3. How do Tuft & Needle and Lull compare in firmness?

The newer Tuft & Needle Original II is marketed as firm, while the Original Lull has a medium-firm feel. This makes Lull more appealing to sleepers who prefer additional cushioning.

4. Are both Tuft & Needle and Lull mattresses suitable for couples?

Yes. Both provide good motion isolation and quiet construction. Lull offers stronger memory foam contouring, while Tuft & Needle provides a more responsive surface for easier movement.

5. Which mattress lasts longer: Tuft & Needle or Lull?

Both can provide several years of comfortable use with proper care. Their actual lifespan depends on body weight, foam durability, maintenance, and foundation quality. Lull offers a longer warranty, but that doesn’t guarantee a longer comfort lifespan.

6. Which mattress has a better sleep trial?

Lull offers a 365-night trial on eligible purchases, while Tuft & Needle provides a 100-night trial. Lull gives buyers considerably more time to evaluate comfort.

7. Do Tuft & Needle and Lull mattresses contain fiberglass?

Tuft & Needle states that its current mattresses are fiberglass-free. For Lull, check the fire-barrier information for the specific mattress version before buying. Never remove a mattress cover unless the manufacturer specifically permits it.

8. Is Tuft & Needle or Lull better for back sleepers?

Both can work for back sleepers. Tuft & Needle Original II may appeal to those wanting firmer support, while Lull is suitable for sleepers who prefer more cushioning. The best choice depends on body weight and comfort preferences.

Still have questions after reading this Tuft & Needle vs Lull mattress comparison? Leave a comment below.