With hundreds of online mattresses on offer, picking the best bed for your needs can be quite a daunting task. However, Tuft & Needle and Puffy offer some of the most outstanding bed-in-a-box mattresses or direct-to-consumer beds.
Tuft & Needle is among the first bed-in-a-box mattresses on the market. They offer three types of mattresses; Tuft & Needle mattress, Tuft & Needle Mint, and Tuft & Needle Hybrid mattresses. On the other hand, Puffy is a company that was started recently but offers five different types of beds; Puffy mattress, Puffy Lux, Puffy Royal, Puffy Lux Hybrid, and Puffy Royal Hybrid.
Comparison Chart: Tuft and Needle VS Puffy Mattress
Tuft and Needle
|Materials||Memory foam layer and proprietary Tuft & Needle foam||gel-infused CloudComfort memory foam layer, transition polyfoam, high-density polyfoam layer|
|Types||T&N mattress, T&N Mint, and T&N Hybrid mattresses||Puffy mattress, Puffy Lux, Puffy Royal, Puffy Lux Hybrid, and Puffy Royal Hybrid|
|Thickness||10,12 and 14-inch||10 inches|
|Shipping||free shipping for customers in the contiguous US states||free to contiguous US states and Canada|
|Trial period||100 nights||101 nights|
|Off-gassing||few days||few days|
|Warranty||10-year non-prorated warranty||Lifetime non-prorated warranty|
|Price:||Check Today’s Price|
Features Comparison: Tuft and Needle Vs Puffy Mattress
Despite these two brands offering a wide range of mattresses, our focus will be on the T&N mattress and Puffy mattress. Both of these beds come with all-foam construction and have a medium-firm feel. However, they are constructed differently, and that’s why we want to compare them and help you find the best bed for your needs.
Before you purchase a new mattress, it’s worth finding out how the mattress is constructed. This will help you pick a bed that will have a feeling that you like. Also, you can determine whether the mattress will sleep cool and last longer or not.
Tuft & Needle
As stated above, Tuft & Needle comes with three different types of mattresses; T&N mattress, T&N Mint, and T&N Hybrid mattresses. Before we look at the Tuft and Needle Mattress, it’s worth knowing what the other T&N beds are made of.
The Tuft & Needle Mint comes with almost the same features as the Tuft & Needle Original mattress. On top of the bed is a cover made up of a blend of polyester and polyamide. This cover is soft to touch and breathable. Next is a 3-inch polyfoam comfort layer. Unlike the T&N Original mattress, this bed comes with an additional 2-inch gel-infused polyfoam layer in the transitional zone. Finally, it has a 7-inch high-density polyfoam in the support core.
The Tuft & Needle Hybrid mattress is also 12-inches, just like the T&N Mint mattress. However, this bed is wildly different from the T&N Original and Mint mattresses. It has three layers; 2-inches of graphite and gel-infused memory foam, 1-inch of springy micro-coils, and 1-inch adaptive poly foam. In addition, this mattress comes with 6-inches of pocketed steel coils and 1-inch of high-density polyfoam in the support core, unlike the other beds.
Our primary focus is on the Tuft & Needle Original mattress. This bed measures 10-inches, which is the industry average. Like the T&N Mint mattress, this bed also comes with a soft and breathable cover constructed from a mix of polyester and polyamide. Beneath this cover is a 3-inch layer of low-density polyfoam, followed by a layer that features gel and graphite. At the same time, the support core comes with a layer of high-density polyfoam.
Unlike T&N that offers three different types of mattresses, Puffy offers five different types of beds. The Puffy mattress, Puffy Lux, Puffy Royal, Puffy Lux Hybrid, and Puffy Royal Hybrid. The Puffy mattress is of the same height as the T&N Original mattress, which is 10-inches in height. However, the Puffy mattress comes with a gel memory foam in its comfort layer, while the T&N Original bed features adaptive foam.
On top of the Puffy mattress is a 100% polyester cover. This cover is not only stain-resistant but as well as washable. Below the cover is 2-inches of low-density gel-infused memory foam. It is followed by a 2-inch layer of temperature-resistant polyfoam, making this mattress somewhat responsive. The last layer is the support or base layer made up of 6-inches of high-density polyfoam layer.
Aside from the Puffy mattress, this brand also offers the Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal all-foam mattresses. But unlike the Puffy mattress, these two beds come with slightly thicker profiles of 12-inches and 14-inches, respectively. This is because they have thicker comfort and support zones than the Puffy bed.
The Puffy Lux is more supportive than the Puffy mattress. Thanks to its dedicated transitional layer and thicker support core. As a result, its edge is more supportive than the Puffy mattress. On the contrary, the Puffy Royal is the most comfortable Puffy bed. Additionally, it’s the most expensive all-foam Puffy bed. With a 5-5-inch comfort zone and a temperature-resistant polyfoam, this bed is very comfortable. Also, it’s bouncy and regulates temperature better than the other two Puffy beds.
The Puffy Lux Hybrid and Puffy Royal Hybrid come with the same features as their all-foam counterpart. However, they have coils in their support core instead of a high-density polyfoam layer. As a result, these beds are more breathable and bounce better than Puffy’s all-foam mattresses.
The durability of a mattress is usually determined by the materials that the bed is made of. Both of these mattresses are well made to last long. Since the beds are made of all-foam layers, expect them to last between 6 and 7. However, since the Puffy mattress is constructed using less dense foams, this mattress may have a shorter lifespan than the Tuft and Needle mattress.
The level of firmness of a mattress determines whether the sleeper sleeps comfortably or not. The Tuft and Needle mattress are slightly firm than the Puffy mattress. On the firmness scale of 10, T&N has a rating of 6.5, while the Puffy mattress has a rating of 5. This means that the Puffy mattress is more suited for lightweight sleepers, while the T&N is best for the back, stomach, and average-weight sleepers.
Sharing a bed with a partner who changes a lot in bed can be pretty challenging. If the bed doesn’t isolate motion well, it may end up distracting your sleep. That’s what happens with most hybrid mattresses. Since Puffy and T&N Original mattresses are made up of memory foam, they limit motion transfer.
However, Puffy is the best as it comes with classic memory foam that does an excellent job of absorbing motion. On the other hand, T&N Original mattress is also good at isolating motion, but the adaptive foam makes it less effective than memory foam.
Edge support is vital if you usually sit or sleep near the edge of the mattress. Memory foam polyfoam and even adaptive foam are known to offer less support around the perimeter. But in this case, the adaptive foam that the T&N mattress comes with provides more support than the Puffy mattress.
However, if you need a very supportive mattress around the perimeter, both Tuft and Needle and Puffy have some exceptional options. The T&N Hybrid mattress and Puffy Lux Hybrid, and Puffy Royal Hybrid have a strong edge because of the springy coils in their support core.
Ease of movement
Some beds can be very uncomfortable as they may make you feel stuck in bed. That’s what most memory foam mattresses do. They hug you closely enough, making you feel like you’re stuck in bed. And since the Puffy mattress is made up of memory foam, it will hug you closely, making moving in and out of bed to be quite challenging.
That’s not the same case with the Tuft and Needle Original mattress. This mattress comes with adaptive foam that makes sleepers feel as if they’re sleeping “on” the mattress than “in” the mattress. Besides, the adaptive foam is more responsive than memory foam, helping the sleeper get out of bed quickly.
Memory foam mattresses usually trap heat, causing some people to sleep hot. However, some beds feature breathable memory foam, such as gel-infused memory foam, and sleep slightly cooler than other beds. For example, even though Puffy mattress comes with a gel-infused memory foam, T&N Original mattress still sleeps cooler than Puffy.
The main reason why hot sleepers may dislike Puffy is because of the 4-inches of memory foam that this mattress comes with. This layer traps a lot of heat, while the adaptive foam that the T&N Original bed comes with is more breathable, allowing hot sleepers to sleep cooler.
If you sleep on a mattress and wake up feeling pain ad soreness in some parts of your body, then you need a bed that relieves pressure well. Most all-foam mattresses are good at alleviating pressure. And since these two beds are made of all-foam layers, they will alleviate pressure and allow the sleeper to sleep comfortably.
Even though both beds are good at relieving pressure, the Puffy mattress relieves pressure best for lightweight individuals, while Puffy relieves pressure best for average-weight and back sleepers.
Most partners prefer a mattress that is responsive and bouncy. Such a bed is great because partners won’t feel stuck as they have fun. However, memory foam beds do not offer such a feature. That’s why both the T&N mattress and Puffy are not suitable for sex. Of course, unless you want a virtually silent bed.
The best beds for sex are the T&N Hybrid mattress, Puffy Lux Hybrid, and Puffy Royal Hybrid. All of these beds are responsive and bouncy. They also make the sleeper feel as if they’re sleeping on top of the bed; thus, they won’t feel stuck.
It is okay for a bed-in-a-box mattress to off-gas. So, you should expect both of these mattresses to produce some gas when unboxed. However, both mattresses are shipped while compressed, and you may have to give them a few days for them to off-gas before sleeping on the bed.
Most direct-to-consumer mattresses come with a free trial period. The period usually lasts from 30 days to several months and up to a year. In addition, T&N and Puffy come with trial periods of their own. The T&N free trial period lasts for up to 100-nights, while the Puffy free trial period lasts 101-nights.
Nonetheless, Puffy has a mandatory 14-day break-in period, while T&N doesn’t have a mandatory break-in period. So, T&N seems to have the better trial period as it doesn’t require customers to break in before returning the mattress.
Tuft and Needle provide free shipping for customers in the contiguous US states, while those in Hawaii and Alaska will have to give a small fee for their mattresses to be shipped. Note that T&N does not ship to Canada. On the contrary, Puffy ships its beds for free to contiguous US states and Canada, while customers in Hawaii and Alaska are also charged a fee for their beds to be shipped.
White glove delivery and old mattress removal
Tuft and Needle offer white-glove delivery and old mattress removal for a fee. However, these services are only limited to customers in the contiguous US states. On the other hand, Puffy mattress does not offer such services at the moment.
In terms of pricing, the Puffy mattress is somewhat more expensive than the Tuft & Needle mattress. However, both of these beds are affordable and last long. Besides, these two brands offer all bed sizes; Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King.
If you’re worried about mattresses coming with defects or damage, you don’t have to be. T&N and Puffy mattresses both cover their products. In addition, T&N offers shoppers a 10-year non-prorated warranty, while Puffy provides a lifetime, non-prorated warranty. So, you will be covered for this period and as long as you don’t violate their warranties.
Who should buy the Tuft and Needle mattress?
- If you desire a mattress with a balanced foam feel, then Tuft and Needle is the best choice for you. Thanks to the adaptive foam that this bed comes with. This layer is also essential as it does a great job of alleviating pressure.
- If you’re a hot sleeper but want an all-foam mattress that sleeps somewhat cool, the Tuft and Needle mattress is the best choice. This is because it has adaptive foam, which is more breathable than gel-memory foam found in Puffy.
- If you like resting on your back or stomach, the Tuft and Needle mattress will be the perfect bed for you. This bed comprises a firmer surface than the Puffy mattress.
- If you’re on a budget, Tuft and Needle is the best bed for you. This mattress is relatively cheaper when compared to Puffy.
Who shouldn’t buy the Tuft and Needle mattress?
- If you relish sleeping on your side, this is not the mattress for you. This bed is ideal for people who sleep on their stomach or back.
- If you want classic memory foam, you won’t get it here. This bed comes with an adaptive foam that gives the sleeper a balanced foam feel.
- Who should buy the Puffy mattress?
- If you want a mattress with classic memory foam, you will love the Puffy mattress. Thanks to the 4-inches of gel memory foam that this bed comes within the comfort layer. It also makes you feel like you’re sleeping in the mattress instead of on the mattress.
- If you want an online mattress with various options to choose from, Puffy is the best option. Unlike the Tuft and Needle that only offers three types of mattresses, Puffy offers five different styles.
- If you’re lightweight or average-weight, you will love sleeping on this bed. The soft memory foam layer will contour closely to your body for a cool and soothing night’s sleep.
- If you desire a bed that can isolate motion properly, you will love the Puffy mattress. This mattress comes with memory foam in the comfort zone, which limits movement to a great extent.
Who shouldn’t buy the Puffy mattress?
- If you love sleeping more on the mattress than in the mattress, Puffy is not the bed for you. This is because this mattress provides a feeling of sleeping more “in” the bed than “on” the bed.
- If you desire a responsive and bouncy mattress, stay away from Puffy. This mattress is not as responsive as Tuft and Needle as it’s made up of memory foam in the comfort zone.
Final Thought on Puffy VS Tuft and Needle
Now that you understand what to expect from Tuft & Needle and Puffy picking the best mattress for your demands and budget shouldn’t be a problem. Puffy is best suited for individuals who want a classic memory foam feel, while Tuft & Needle is best for those looking for a balanced foam feel.
Both mattresses have excellent warranties and industry average sleep trials. Besides, if you enjoy sleeping on your back or stomach, consider getting the Tuft & Needle mattress as it provides more support. On the contrary, Puffy will offer pressure decent pressure relief to lightweight sleepers.
We hope you can now select a mattress of your choice as they are both favorably priced, even though Puffy is slightly costly.